- At the re-opening of St. Anne's Church, Father Kieran ~ guest star Todd Stashwick finds himself in a great deal of trouble after a run-in with a witch from his past.
- Marcel ~ Charles Michael Davis and Rebekah ~ Claire Holt grow concerned when the reemergence of someone they once knew threatens to expose secrets they've kept buried for nearly a century.
- Elsewhere, Sophie ~ Daniella Pineda is shocked when a discovery is made at the cemetery, but she soon realizes things may not be as they seem.
- With the full moon looming, Hayley ~ Phoebe Tonkin lets Rebekah in on her plan to throw a party for her werewolf clan, but things take a dangerous turn when uninvited guests arrive.
- Meanwhile, Cami ~ Leah Pipes is conflicted when she makes a difficult decision involving the safety of Father Kieran, and Elijah ~ Daniel Gillies finds himself facing his own dilemma when he has to choose between Hayley and his siblings.
- Finally, when one of his plans fails, Klaus ~ Joseph Morgan takes drastic measures in the Cauldron, resulting in dangerous repercussions that affect everyone involved.